Comparison: Organic Valley Grassmilk vs St Benoit vs Clover DHA Omega3 Organic Whole Milk
2022-05-24
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220524_064042093.497db17e66981e18.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050539085.cd55f00ec2844348.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_052522231.422ed50ca3030641.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_052609361.3ac11b911e549730.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050811513.eb81e62111886fdb.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050802963.496acaecf01f7a21.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/2.5a90e399da4e4ada.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050825735.7ee2fe439cc2e844.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_051418995.4fab9539a6224923.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/1.983a2ad45d6b4384.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050757054.48b80854ef0d6355.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050547702.ead14ef73b8864c9.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220524_064017897.b98182e6ea3bcdf5.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_052528601.32a404a1fe885692.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220524_064015764.f7e1cf7c7e72d69f.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050743378.2caecd8c018340ec.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220524_064039724.9e2cb1abdc56e6d3.jpg)
![](https://milkcritic.com/processed_images/PXL_20220525_050542680.e7db0f7904655b97.jpg)
Three fine milks, in three glasses.
Organic Valley Grass Milk
Fresh creamy Slightly sweet at the end
A
St Benoit
Rich creamy. Slightly eggy taste at end (and throughout compared to the fresh taste of grass milk or clover)
Best overall. The grass milk is very close, in a different style.
A
Clover DHA Omega3 Organic Whole Milk
Mostly fresh taste. Quite creamy After taste is a very faint droplet of tea flavor
It is the after taste that brings this milk down from A. Comparing it with two other A milks highlights how close it is. Alone I would be thinking more about B+ (but probably still give A-).
A-
Conclusion
St Benoit is the best of these, followed by Organic Valley, with Clover in third place.
The distinction is pretty clear, but they are all fine milks.